Posts: 216
Threads: 1
Joined: Jul 2018
Reputation:
4
09-01-2026, 11:44 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-01-2026, 11:54 PM by Stojanm.)
Thought I would do a thread listing all of the current squad and whether we should Keep or Sell over the next few transfer windows. This is based on us staying up in the Premier League this season
Please add anyone I may have missed
Goalkeepers
Sels - Keep
John - Sell he’s a liability
Gunn - Keep as number 2
Defenders
Aina - Keep
Savona - Keep. I like him and think he will improve
Williams - Keep
Zinchenko - End loan now
Cubiano - Keep, although none of us have seen him play
Murillo - Keep if we can
Milenkovic - Keep
Morato - Sell, too error prone
Cunha - Keep, I think he will become a good player for Forest if he’s given a chance
Abbott - Keep
Boly - Sell in this window
Midfielders
Anderson - Sell in the Summer if someone is crazy enough to pay £80 - £100 million. Very good player but does not score or assist enough for me
Sangare - Keep
Yates - Keep
Dominguez - Keep
Gibbs-White - Keep if we can
Luiz - Kerp if he can stay fit
McAtee - Sell in this window and use the money to buy a striker or box to box goal scoring midfielder
Wingers
Hutchinson - Keep
Hudson Odoi - Keep
N’Doye - Sell
Bakwa - Keep but us a close call. Would like to see more of him and if continues to play as he is now then Sell
Strikers
Awoniyi - Sell absolutely terrible player now
Wood - Kerp
Jesus - Keep, I think he will improve his giskscoring given time and the right service
Kalimuendo - Keep. I think he is a good goal scorer and would work really well playing off a big number 9
Posts: 12,011
Threads: 16
Joined: Jun 2018
Reputation:
115
I like that McAtee is so completely anonymous that you’ve forgotten to include him.
Posts: 216
Threads: 1
Joined: Jul 2018
Reputation:
4
(09-01-2026, 11:49 PM)Salvatore Matrecano Wrote: I like that McAtee is so completely anonymous that you’ve forgotten to include him.
Dam. Good point. Sell, Sell, Sell
Will add him now
Posts: 4,396
Threads: 0
Joined: May 2018
Reputation:
49
Zinchenko, Morato, Boly, Taiwo, Victor are all surplus.
Ndoye and McAtee have the talent, but god knows they need to wake up.
Bakwa - I think he will come good.
need a left back, forward and prob a midfield upgrade
Posts: 2,393
Threads: 3
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
19
Location: Deeside
(09-01-2026, 11:49 PM)Salvatore Matrecano Wrote: I like that McAtee is so completely anonymous that you’ve forgotten to include him.
Haha brilliant :Up Yours:
Posts: 2,393
Threads: 3
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
19
Location: Deeside
The 3 hooked at half time can go and Morato can go with them
Rest hang on to, Ndoye is up and down but he's too expensive to bin
Posts: 2,542
Threads: 0
Joined: Jun 2018
Reputation:
26
Mcatee has been terrible... Always suspicious of reports that tell you how much a manager like Pep rates a player despite never playing them. Always feels like it's just a way to hype up the price.
On the other hand, we said similar about Neco Williams and he is now one of the first names on the team sheet and has become Mr consistent and probably our best player this season. It took him time though and there were lots on here who were critical of him in those first few seasons. I guess the improvement we've seen with Sangare is another reason why some of these foreign signings need more time to bed in.
Posts: 2,393
Threads: 3
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
19
Location: Deeside
(10-01-2026, 12:24 AM)Plymouth red Wrote: Mcatee has been terrible... Always suspicious of reports that tell you how much a manager like Pep rates a player despite never playing them. Always feels like it's just a way to hype up the price.
On the other hand, we said similar about Neco Williams and he is now one of the first names on the team sheet and has become Mr consistent and probably our best player this season. It took him time though and there were lots on here who were critical of him in those first few seasons. I guess the improvement we've seen with Sangare is another reason why some of these foreign signings need more time to bed in.
Neco was playing in and out for Liverpool tbf, it'd be like signing Connor Bradley now.
McAtee was the wrong signing, Harvey Elliott on loan was the one
Posts: 3,095
Threads: 2
Joined: Jul 2018
Reputation:
17
(09-01-2026, 11:44 PM)Stojanm Wrote: Thought I would do a thread listing all of the current squad and whether we should Keep or Sell over the next few transfer windows. This is based on us staying up in the Premier League this season
Please add anyone I may have missed
Goalkeepers
Sels - Keep
John - Sell he’s a liability
Gunn - Keep as number 2
Defenders
Aina - Keep
Savona - Keep. I like him and think he will improve
Williams - Keep
Zinchenko - End loan now
Cubiano - Keep, although none of us have seen him play
Murillo - Keep if we can
Milenkovic - Keep
Morato - Sell, too error prone
Cunha - Keep, I think he will become a good player for Forest if he’s given a chance
Abbott - Keep
Boly - Sell in this window
Midfielders
Anderson - Sell in the Summer if someone is crazy enough to pay £80 - £100 million. Very good player but does not score or assist enough for me
Sangare - Keep
Yates - Keep
Dominguez - Keep
Gibbs-White - Keep if we can
Luiz - Kerp if he can stay fit
McAtee - Sell in this window and use the money to buy a striker or box to box goal scoring midfielder
Wingers
Hutchinson - Keep
Hudson Odoi - Keep
N’Doye - Sell
Bakwa - Keep but us a close call. Would like to see more of him and if continues to play as he is now then Sell
Strikers
Awoniyi - Sell absolutely terrible player now
Wood - Kerp
Jesus - Keep, I think he will improve his giskscoring given time and the right service
Kalimuendo - Keep. I think he is a good goal scorer and would work really well playing off a big number 9
Ooo id like to have seen one of these when hughton was here.
Garner under performing
Zinc playing poor.
Spencer, lowe the same.
Cooper came in got them playing to there strengths and they went from to get rid to keeps. Quality players dont just turn crap, they play how they are coached too
Posts: 19,385
Threads: 602
Joined: May 2018
Reputation:
206
Location: Athens
(10-01-2026, 09:12 AM)northeastred Wrote: (09-01-2026, 11:44 PM)Stojanm Wrote: Thought I would do a thread listing all of the current squad and whether we should Keep or Sell over the next few transfer windows. This is based on us staying up in the Premier League this season
Please add anyone I may have missed
Goalkeepers
Sels - Keep
John - Sell he’s a liability
Gunn - Keep as number 2
Defenders
Aina - Keep
Savona - Keep. I like him and think he will improve
Williams - Keep
Zinchenko - End loan now
Cubiano - Keep, although none of us have seen him play
Murillo - Keep if we can
Milenkovic - Keep
Morato - Sell, too error prone
Cunha - Keep, I think he will become a good player for Forest if he’s given a chance
Abbott - Keep
Boly - Sell in this window
Midfielders
Anderson - Sell in the Summer if someone is crazy enough to pay £80 - £100 million. Very good player but does not score or assist enough for me
Sangare - Keep
Yates - Keep
Dominguez - Keep
Gibbs-White - Keep if we can
Luiz - Kerp if he can stay fit
McAtee - Sell in this window and use the money to buy a striker or box to box goal scoring midfielder
Wingers
Hutchinson - Keep
Hudson Odoi - Keep
N’Doye - Sell
Bakwa - Keep but us a close call. Would like to see more of him and if continues to play as he is now then Sell
Strikers
Awoniyi - Sell absolutely terrible player now
Wood - Kerp
Jesus - Keep, I think he will improve his giskscoring given time and the right service
Kalimuendo - Keep. I think he is a good goal scorer and would work really well playing off a big number 9
Ooo id like to have seen one of these when hughton was here.
Garner under performing
Zinc playing poor.
Spencer, lowe the same.
Cooper came in got them playing to there strengths and they went from to get rid to keeps. Quality players dont just turn crap, they play how they are coached too
100% this ^^
Panic on the streets of London
Posts: 19,385
Threads: 602
Joined: May 2018
Reputation:
206
Location: Athens
Does this thread include the manager?
Sell.
Panic on the streets of London
Posts: 1,759
Threads: 0
Joined: May 2018
Reputation:
9
(10-01-2026, 09:33 AM)Sniffer Dog (Admin) Wrote: (10-01-2026, 09:12 AM)northeastred Wrote: (09-01-2026, 11:44 PM)Stojanm Wrote: Thought I would do a thread listing all of the current squad and whether we should Keep or Sell over the next few transfer windows. This is based on us staying up in the Premier League this season
Please add anyone I may have missed
Goalkeepers
Sels - Keep
John - Sell he’s a liability
Gunn - Keep as number 2
Defenders
Aina - Keep
Savona - Keep. I like him and think he will improve
Williams - Keep
Zinchenko - End loan now
Cubiano - Keep, although none of us have seen him play
Murillo - Keep if we can
Milenkovic - Keep
Morato - Sell, too error prone
Cunha - Keep, I think he will become a good player for Forest if he’s given a chance
Abbott - Keep
Boly - Sell in this window
Midfielders
Anderson - Sell in the Summer if someone is crazy enough to pay £80 - £100 million. Very good player but does not score or assist enough for me
Sangare - Keep
Yates - Keep
Dominguez - Keep
Gibbs-White - Keep if we can
Luiz - Kerp if he can stay fit
McAtee - Sell in this window and use the money to buy a striker or box to box goal scoring midfielder
Wingers
Hutchinson - Keep
Hudson Odoi - Keep
N’Doye - Sell
Bakwa - Keep but us a close call. Would like to see more of him and if continues to play as he is now then Sell
Strikers
Awoniyi - Sell absolutely terrible player now
Wood - Kerp
Jesus - Keep, I think he will improve his giskscoring given time and the right service
Kalimuendo - Keep. I think he is a good goal scorer and would work really well playing off a big number 9
Ooo id like to have seen one of these when hughton was here.
Garner under performing
Zinc playing poor.
Spencer, lowe the same.
Cooper came in got them playing to there strengths and they went from to get rid to keeps. Quality players dont just turn crap, they play how they are coached too
100% this ^^
:  :
|
